Our D&D game

Use whichever one is the funnest to play

The advanced ones I think. They cover your character slowly go insane from fear, and covers dangerous horror and subtle horror.

But.... I thought we were the bad guys?

We are, but you're level 2. There's only so much evil one can perpetrate at level 2.

Ah, I see, so when we see REALLY evil evil we do go a bit mad/crazy?

Of course! Naturally, that'll only make you more evil in turn. And bear in mind that at around level 10, you'll be properly evil. You'll be doing 3 attacks a turn or something silly, Jack'll be a vampire, and Hesoliv should be raising the dead like there's no tomorrow.